News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Can't fight the fire 

Can't fight the fire

03 Nov, 2010 11:30 PM
CAPE JERVIS - Do you call the CFS in the event of a wind turbine fire?

While it might seem like the right thing to do, according to group officer for the Southern Fleurieu CFS Mr Greg Crawford, there is little to nothing the CFS can do in this situation, as officers found out at the weekend.

Last Saturday at 2.33 pm, the Southern Fleurieu CFS group was alerted to a fire at the Starfish Hill Wind Farm, near Cape Jervis, in which a turbine had caught alight.

The fire caused $3,000,000 in damage.

On arrival, CFS officers could do little but watch the blaze from half a kilometre away, as the situation was deemed too dangerous to approach.

"There was not a damn thing you could do about it," said Mr Crawford of the turbine fire.

When Work Safe arrived to the scene, CFS officers were told to retreat a further 500 metres away from the fire, as the blades continued to spin.

"There were tips of the blades flying some distance," said Mr Crawford.

"You could go no closer than a kilometre away."

CFS officers kept watch for spot fires, but were unable to extinguish those close to the turbine.

Water cannot be used to extinguish the cause of a wind turbine fire, as the turbine's hub contains a large electrical network and from ground to blade tip, the turbines stand at 100 metres tall.

In the event of a wind turbine fire during the fire season, aerial support could aid CFS by extinguishing fires caused by embers around the turbine.

Mr Crawford said the Southern Fleurieu CFS Group had received a bulletin from management detailing that little can be done in the event of a wind turbine fire due to the threat it poses to officers.

He said the Southern Fleurieu CFS Group is in ongoing discussions with the regional CFS officer and representatives from Starfish Hill Wind Farm on the issue.

MORE PAGE 7

A spokesperson for Transfield Services Infrastructure Fund, the organisation in charge of Starfish Hill Wind Farm, said the company has a huge emphasis on safety.

He said a Work Safe team are on site, monitoring operations closely and all safety measures are in place.

"As far as I'm aware, all safety precautions were taken (during the incident)," said the spokesperson.

He said the blades have now been clamped and the safety risk has been significantly alleviated.

Southern Fleurieu resident Barry Webb captured a photo of the destroyed turbine on Sunday and said he, along with many, have concerns of the high danger risks a turbine fire could pose to communities.

"They (wind turbines) are normally located in areas that are not easily accessible (to emergency crews)," said Mr Webb.

"The situation has the potential to be quite serious."

The Starfish Hill wind turbine fire is the third in South Australia since 2006, with a blaze at the Lake Bonney Wind Farm in January 2006, and another at Cathedral Rocks Wind Farm, Port Lincoln in February 2009.

Both occurred during peak fire season.

A spokesperson for the District Council of Yankalilla said while council can provide advice to landowners concerned over the issue, the Starfish Hill Wind Farm is not council's responsibility.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I live adjacent to the proposed Origin Energy wind Development at Collaby Hill. All the residents of Beetaloo Valley are rightly concerned about the fire risk in summer, and many of us are extremely concerned about the additional risk wind turbine fires will bring if they occur on days of fire danger - for example there are currently no restrictions on the operation of wind turbines on extreme and catastrophic fire days, and we have been advised by the CFS that there are restrictions on the operation of aerial water bombers in the vicinity of wind turbines in the event of a fire. We have also been advised that the CFS can do little more than mop up any spot fires because it is too dangerous to go closer than 300 metres (confirmed by events at Starfish Hill). It is yet another example of the inadequate regulations concerning the safe operation of wind turbines and the folly of siting wind turbines too close to homes, in addition to the adverse health effects which are now being described across the world. Black Saturday in Victoria does not need to be repeated in country regions across Australia resulting from turbine fires, yet this is an increasingly likely scenario.
Posted by Dr Sarah Laurie, 10/11/2010 11:17:01 PM, on Victor Harbor Times
We are also facing the prospect of more wind turbines around us here in Eudunda and Robertstoen, With some very precious heritage listed scrub and rare bird and reptile species a fire would be disastrous. Mr Rann need s to sit up and take notice - comfy in his safe city seat - as if the wind turbimnes dont present enough other issues, now we need to add fire to the growing list.

Tania Naveill Eudunda

Posted by Tania Neville, 11/11/2010 11:02:24 AM, on Victor Harbor Times
Lucky it wasn't a coal-fired power station or a nuclear one!

Then we'd be in trouble!

Wind energy is the go.

Posted by PPP, 12/11/2010 9:32:24 AM, on Victor Harbor Times
Sorry PPP, an anonymous comment is a worthless comment. If one new generation nuclear power station can replace 2500 crackpot windmills, and reuse 99% of the spent nuclear fuel used whilst providing 100% base load power, I think its worth investigating at the very least! One gas power station alone can provide 800 megawatts of base load power and almost halve the emissions of a coal fired power station overnight! Look at the Mortlake gas power station website in Victoria for the statistics. So no, erratic island life technology like wind turbines are not the way to go.
Posted by vyvyan groves, 1/03/2011 2:58:41 PM, on Victor Harbor Times

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
FORTUNE UP IN SMOKE: The damage caused in Saturday's wind turbine fire at Starfish Hill, Cape Jervis is estimated at $3 million.
FORTUNE UP IN SMOKE: The damage caused in Saturday's wind turbine fire at Starfish Hill, Cape Jervis is estimated at $3 million.
FORTUNE UP IN SMOKE: The damage caused in Saturday's wind turbine fire at Starfish Hill, Cape Jervis is estimated at $3 million.
FORTUNE UP IN SMOKE: The damage caused in Saturday's wind turbine fire at Starfish Hill, Cape Jervis is estimated at $3 million.

Most popular articles




The Times







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...